This
is a determination of the Railroad Retirement
Board concerning the status of R. J. Corman
Switching Co. (RCSC) as an employer under
the Railroad Retirement Act (45 U.S.C. §231
et seq.) and the Railroad Unemployment Insurance
Act (45 U.S.C. §351 et seq.).
There was no verified notice of exemption
filed with the Surface Transportation Board
(STB).
Information regarding RCSC was furnished
by Mr. Brad Brown, Contracts/Property Manager
for RCSC. According to Mr. Brown, RCSC is
owned by R. J. Corman Railroad Group, LLC
and does not have a Chief Executive Officer.
Mr. Brown stated that RCSC began operations
on January 3, 2001 and has five employees,
3 full time employees and 2 part-time employees,
who were first compensated on January 3,
2001. RCSC does not own any railroad track
and does not interchange with any railroads,
according to Mr. Brown. Mr. Brown stated
that RCSC spends 100 percent of its time
providing “intra-plant switching services
for ThyssenKrupp Budd Company at its automotive
stamping and assembly plant in Shelbyville,
Kentucky” and that RCSC’s “operations
are not subject to STB jurisdiction and
therefore STB approval was not sought for
such operations.” Mr. Brown stated
that Norfolk Southern Railway Company delivers
and removes railroad cars to and from the
ThyssenKrupp Budd Company plant. RCSC does
not own any railroad equipment, according
to Mr. Brown. Mr. Brown stated that RCSC
uses two locomotives that it leases from
R. J. Corman Railroad/Memphis Line (B.A.
No. 2598). RCSC is owned and operated by
the same persons as R. J. Corman Railroad
Company/Memphis Line, R. J. Corman Railroad
Company/Cleveland Line (B.A. No. 5333),
R. J. Corman Railroad Company/Pennsylvania
Lines Inc. (B.A. No. 2367), R. J. Corman
Railroad Company/Western Ohio Lines (B.A.
No. 2356) and R. J. Corman Railroad Company/Allentown
Lines, Inc. (B.A. No. 2370).
Section 1(a)(1) of the Railroad Retirement
Act (45 U.S.C. §231(a)(1)), insofar
as relevant here, defines a covered employer
as:
(i) any carrier by railroad subject to
the jurisdiction of the Surface Transportation
Board under Part A of subtitle IV of title
49, United States Code;
(ii) any company which is directly or
indirectly owned or controlled by, or under
common control with, one or more employers
as defined in paragraph (i) of this subdivision,
and which operates any equipment or facility
or performs any service (except trucking
service, casual service, and the casual
operation of equipment or facilities) in
connection with the transportation of passengers
or property by railroad ***.
Sections 1(a) and 1(b) of the Railroad Unemployment
Insurance Act (45 U.S.C. §§351(a)
and (b)) contain substantially similar definitions,
as does section 3231 of the Railroad Retirement
Tax Act (26 U.S.C. §3231).
The evidence of record shows that RCSC
is a switching railway which provides services
to only one customer, ThyssenKrupp Budd
Company. The Surface Transportation Board
(STB) has jurisdiction over common carriers
engaged in the interstate transportation
of passengers or property by railroad pursuant
to section 10501 of title 49 of the United
States Code. A common carrier may be defined
in general as one which holds itself out
to the public as engaging in the business
of transporting people or property from
place to place for compensation. It is the
right of the public to demand service that
is the real criterion determinative of an
entity’s character as a common carrier.
In contrast, a private carrier is one which,
without making it a vocation or holding
itself out to the public as ready to act
for all who desire the service, undertakes
by special agreement in a particular instance
only, to transport property or persons from
place to place. Private carriers thus undertake
not to carry for all persons indiscriminately,
but rather transport only for those with
whom they see fit to contract individually.
The RRB has followed the distinction made
by the Surface Transportation Board, formerly
the Interstate Commerce Commission, which
is judicially supported in The Tap Line
Cases, 234 U. S. 1 (1913); also International
Detective Service, Inc. v. Interstate Commerce
Commission, 595 F. 2d 862, 865 (D.C. Cir.
1979).
Additionally, the term “railroad’
under the ICC Termination Act of 1995 includes
a switch, spur, track, terminal, or terminal
facility as well as a freight depot, yard,
and ground used or necessary for transportation
(49 U. S. C. §10102(6)(C)). It is well
settled that a terminal or switching company
is a common carrier rather than a private
carrier if it holds itself out to be one,
acts in that capacity, and is dealt with
in that capacity by railroads in general.
U. S. v. California, 297 U.S. 175 (1936).
Consistent with this, the Board has held
terminal railroads to be covered employers
under the RRA and RUIA where they act in
the capacity of a common carrier subject
to the ICC Termination Act of 1995.
In this case, the information contained
in the file indicates that RCSC is not a
common carrier, but operates instead as
a private carrier which performs intraplant
switching for a single customer. Consistent
with the earlier decisions of the Board,
we hold that RCSC is not an employer under
the Railroad Retirement and Railroad Unemployment
Insurance Acts. |